Healthcare Laws, Ethics & Counselling Sk

Cheatsheet Content

Legal Framework in Healthcare A robust legal framework governs medical practice in India, covering patient rights, professional responsibilities, and legal repercussions of misconduct. Medico-legal knowledge is essential for healthcare professionals. Patient Rights and Responsibilities Patient Rights Right to Information: Clear, authentic, intelligible information on diagnosis, treatment, risks, and outcomes. Example: Doctor explains success rate and side effects of chemotherapy in simple language. Right to Records: Patients can obtain copies of their medical records without delay. Right to Emergency Care: Hospitals must provide basic emergency care without upfront payment. Right to Privacy & Confidentiality: Medical information must be confidential; privacy respected during examinations. Right to Informed Consent: Written consent required for invasive/hazardous procedures, with full disclosure of risks, alternatives, and benefits. Right to a Second Opinion: Patients can seek a second opinion from another qualified practitioner. Right to Refuse Treatment: Patients can refuse treatment after being informed of consequences. Right to Non-Discrimination: Care without discrimination based on gender, religion, race, or socioeconomic status. Right to be Heard: Patients can file complaints and seek redressal for grievances. Patient Responsibilities Provide Complete Information: Accurate medical history for proper diagnosis. Comply with Treatment: Follow doctor's instructions diligently; inform if unable to comply. Respect Staff & Rules: Respect hospital staff and adhere to regulations. Pay Bills: Settle hospital bills and understand treatment costs. Medical Malpractice Occurs when a healthcare provider deviates from the accepted standard of care, causing harm. Claims can be pursued under civil, criminal, or consumer protection law. Civil Negligence Seeks monetary compensation for damages under tort law. Proving requires: Duty of care owed to patient. Breach of that duty. Breach caused harm. Example: Surgeon leaves surgical sponge inside a patient, leading to a civil suit for damages. Criminal Negligence Requires "gross negligence" or recklessness. Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (2005): Guidelines to protect doctors from frivolous criminal charges. Example: Anaesthesiologist, under influence of alcohol, administers incorrect dosage, leading to patient's death, warranting criminal charges. Consumer Protection Act (CPA) Medical services covered under CPA ( Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha, 1995 ). Patients can file complaints for "deficiency in service". Example: Patient pays for surgery, but complications arise due to lack of proper care; compensation sought via consumer court. Medico-Legal Aspects of Reproductive Health Impotence Medico-legal relevance: Ground for nullity of marriage under Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, if present at marriage. Defense in rape and sexual offense cases. Example: Wife files for annulment due to husband's impotence; confirmed by medical examination. Sterility Medico-legal relevance: Inability to reproduce; not necessarily impotence. Relevant in disputed paternity cases. Failed Sterilization: Doctor liable if standard protocols not followed or patient not informed of failure rate. Consent: Written, informed consent from patient (and spouse for married individuals). Regulations: Procedure must be performed according to proper indications; sterilization without consent is illegal. Example: Woman becomes pregnant after tubectomy; doctor faces legal challenge if proper counseling on failure possibility was not given. Artificial Insemination (AI) Legal Status: No specific law in India; ICMR guidelines exist. Consent & Confidentiality: Written informed consent from both spouses; donor identity kept confidential. Medico-legal Issues: Child's legitimacy and inheritance rights. Child born via donor sperm is illegitimate unless formally adopted by husband. Medico-Legal Aspects of Psychiatric & Mental Health Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 Superseded Mental Health Act, 1987. Emphasizes patient rights, autonomy, dignified care. Decriminalized attempted suicide. Key Provisions: Advance Directive: Patients can create written preferences for mental healthcare and appoint a nominated representative. Informed Consent: Mandates informed consent for all psychiatric treatments, considering patient's capacity to consent. Involuntary Admission: Regulated process with strict legal oversight. Criminal Responsibility: IPC Section 84 addresses criminal responsibility for persons with "unsoundness of mind". Example: Person with bipolar disorder signs contract in manic state; court may void if mental capacity was lacking. Toxicology: Laws Related to Toxicology Poisons Act, 1919: Regulates possession, import, and sale of poisons; mandates licenses and record-keeping. Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940: Regulates manufacture, sale, and distribution of drugs and cosmetics, with specific schedules for poisonous/restricted substances. Indian Penal Code (IPC): Section 328: Causing hurt by poison with intent to commit an offense. Section 302: Administering poison to cause death (murder). Role of Medical Professionals: Legal duty to inform police in suspected poisoning cases. Example: Doctor treats patient with poisoning symptoms; records symptoms in medico-legal report for police investigation after patient's death. Giving Evidence in Police Investigation Medical professionals play a crucial role in providing evidence in criminal cases. Medical Evidence: Corroborates/contradicts witness testimony; includes medical reports, post-mortem findings, forensic analysis. Procedures (CrPC): Section 53: Police (sub-inspector rank or above) can request medical examination of an accused. Section 53A: Details procedure for examining accused in rape cases; requires female medical practitioner for female accused. Section 164A: Governs medical examination of rape victims; requires consent and detailed report from registered medical practitioner. Dying Declaration: Doctor can record if Magistrate's presence is delayed and patient is lucid. Expert Witness: Registered medical practitioner can give expert evidence in court. Example: Doctor who performed post-mortem gives evidence on cause of death, nature of injuries, and likely weapon. Organ Transplantation The Transplantation of Human Organs Act (THOA), 1994, and amendments govern organ/tissue transplantation in India. Regulation: Prohibits commercial dealing in human organs; establishes regulatory framework. Appropriate Authority: State/Central governments appoint authorities to oversee transplantation activities. Brain Death: Act provides legal definition; board of doctors must certify for cadaveric donation. Consent: Informed consent from donor is mandatory; special procedures for live non-relative donations. Example: Patient needs kidney transplant; brother volunteers. Hospital committee reviews, ensures altruistic donation, obtains informed consent from both. Euthanasia (Mercy Killing) Legal Status: Active euthanasia (administering lethal substance) is illegal, considered murder. Passive Euthanasia: Legalized under strict guidelines by Supreme Court ( Common Cause v. Union of India, 2018 ). Involves withdrawing life-sustaining treatment for terminally ill patients with no hope of recovery. Living Will: Judgment allows "living wills" or advance medical directives for withdrawal of life support in irreversible terminal illness/persistent vegetative state. Aruna Shanbaug Case: Landmark 2011 Supreme Court judgment laid groundwork for passive euthanasia, though it denied active euthanasia in that case. Example: Terminally ill patient with living will, in persistent vegetative state. Family and medical team follow legal process for withdrawal of life support. Diagnosis, Prescriptions, and Administration of Drugs Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940: Regulates import, manufacture, distribution, and sale of drugs, ensuring quality, safety, efficacy. Code of Medical Ethics (NMC): Provides ethical guidelines for medical professionals. Diagnosis: Requires thorough clinical examination. Negligent diagnosis causing harm can lead to legal action. Prescriptions: Must be clear, legible, include drug name, dosage, administration instructions. Prescribing secret/unproven remedies is unethical. Drug Administration: Must follow prescribed dosage/route. Negligence can lead to serious legal consequences. Example: Doctor misdiagnoses, prescribes wrong medication, causing severe allergic reaction; potential medical malpractice claim. Anaesthesia and Surgery Informed Consent: Written consent mandatory for all surgical procedures and anaesthesia. Anaesthetist must explain risks. Standard of Care: Anaesthetists and surgeons must adhere to the standard of care expected of a reasonably competent professional. Professional Indemnity: Recommended for anaesthetists and surgeons to protect against legal actions. Record-keeping: Detailed and accurate records critical for all procedures, including anaesthesia. Vital evidence in legal disputes. Post-operative Care: Surgeon and anaesthetist responsible for post-operative care and pain management. Example: Patient suffers nerve injury during surgery. Detailed records of procedure and monitoring data are crucial to determine if standard of care was met. Counselling Skills: Introduction Counselling is a crucial skill in healthcare for psychological support to patients, families, and staff, improving health outcomes and operational efficiency. It is an interpersonal process empowering individuals to understand their situation, explore feelings, and make informed decisions. Core Principles of Counselling Skills Foundational principles for effective counselling (Carl Rogers' person-centered approach). Empathy: Ability to understand and communicate client's feelings/experiences from their perspective. Unconditional Positive Regard: Accepting and respecting client as a person of value, regardless of behavior/beliefs. Genuineness (Congruence): Being authentic and transparent; counsellor's words, thoughts, and actions are consistent. Active Listening: Fully engaging with verbal/non-verbal communication, paying attention, reflecting. Confidentiality: Fundamental ethical principle; client information remains private, with specific legal/ethical exceptions. Cultural Sensitivity: Awareness of how one's culture and biases affect worldview, and how clients' cultures shape values/beliefs. Growth of Counselling Services Field evolved from developmental/vocational issues to wide range of psychological, social, health-related concerns. Specialized Needs: Counselling for chronic illnesses (cancer, diabetes), HIV/AIDS, traumatic injuries. Family Involvement: Therapeutic support for family members, especially for addiction/end-of-life care. Mental Health Focus: Crisis intervention, grief counseling, anxiety/depression support. Performance Enhancement: Counselling for healthcare staff to manage burnout, resolve conflicts, improve interpersonal effectiveness. Counselling services have moved from a niche to an essential component of holistic patient care, driven by mental health awareness, social dynamics, and progressive healthcare laws. Factors Driving Growth of Counselling Services Addressing Stigma Historically, mental health support was stigmatized in India. Public awareness campaigns, celebrity advocacy, education have normalized therapy. Example: Celebrity-led foundations bring mental health issues into public discourse, encouraging help-seeking. Changing Social Norms and Lifestyles Urbanization, globalization, breakdown of traditional joint families lead to increased stress, anxiety, relationship issues. Counselling increasingly sought for work-life balance, relationships, societal expectations. Example: Patient seeks counselling for high-pressure job stress or transitioning family structure complexities. Government Initiatives and Policy Changes National Mental Health Programme (1982): Acknowledged need for mental healthcare beyond specialized hospitals; integrated mental health into general healthcare. National Health Policy (2017): Recognized mental health as national priority; integrated mental healthcare into primary services (e.g., Ayushman Bharat). National Tele Mental Health Programme (Tele MANAS) (2022): 24/7, toll-free helpline for tele-counselling and referral support, improving access. Example: Tele MANAS effective in reaching individuals in remote areas with limited access to mental health professionals. Accessibility Through Technology COVID-19 pandemic accelerated telehealth/online counselling adoption, addressing rural accessibility. Digital platforms made counselling convenient, private, destigmatizing. Example: Patient in small town connects with licensed professional online, avoiding travel. Healthcare Laws and Their Role in Counselling Services Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 Empowers Patients: Promotes patient autonomy, protects rights of individuals with mental illness, decriminalized attempted suicide, introduced "advance directive". Ensures Accessibility: Mandates government provide affordable, quality mental healthcare and counselling at all facilities. Example: Patient can formally document wishes for future mental healthcare treatment, gaining control over care. HIV and AIDS (Prevention and Control) Act, 2017 Protects Privacy & Prohibits Discrimination: Safeguards rights of individuals with HIV/AIDS, mandates informed consent for HIV testing, prohibits discrimination in healthcare services. Requires Counselling: Explicitly requires government to provide HIV prevention, testing, treatment, and counselling services. Example: Person seeking HIV test must give informed consent; counsellor provides pre- and post-test counselling. The Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002 Upholds Professional Standards: Broader ethical framework for all medical practitioners. Ensures Patient-Centric Care: Emphasizes patient-centric care, confidentiality, professional integrity (cornerstones of ethical counselling). Example: Medical professionals, including counsellors, adhere to regulations regarding patient confidentiality with sensitive information. The Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act Mandates Counselling: Explicitly includes mental health preservation as valid reason for pregnancy termination. Anguish from rape presumed grave injury, highlighting need for compassionate counselling. Example: Minor/rape victim seeking abortion; comprehensive counselling integral to address psychological well-being. Ethical Considerations Growth of counselling services highlights need for strict ethical guidelines. Competence: Counsellors must practice within expertise, continuously update qualifications. Informed Consent: Clients fully informed about counselling process, fees, confidentiality, risks. Confidentiality: Maintaining client information in strict confidence (with legal exceptions). Dual Relationships: Counsellors avoid relationships outside professional context that harm client or impair judgment. Cultural Sensitivity: Counsellors are culturally sensitive, aware of biases, adapt approach to respect client's cultural values. Approaches to Counselling Various theoretical approaches guide counselling; effective counsellors integrate multiple methods. Person-Centered Therapy (Humanistic): Carl Rogers; clients have inherent potential for growth. Emphasizes empathy, unconditional positive regard, genuineness. Example: Counsellor listens empathetically to terminally ill patient, accepting feelings of anger/fear, empowering processing emotions. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): Helps clients identify/challenge negative or irrational thought patterns/behaviors, develop new coping skills. Example: Nurse struggling with burnout counselled using CBT; identifies unhelpful thoughts, learns stress-management techniques. Solution-Focused Brief Therapy: Focuses on strengths, resources, past successes. Helps clients set specific, achievable goals. Example: Stroke patient discouraged by slow progress. Counsellor helps identify small goals, focuses on progress made. Motivational Interviewing: Explores/resolves client's ambivalence toward change. Used to promote lifestyle modifications for chronic conditions. Example: Diabetic patient resistant to diet change. Counsellor uses open-ended questions to explore motivations, identify reasons for wanting to be healthier. Process of Counselling Structured, collaborative journey between counsellor and client to address psychological, social, emotional challenges. Typically divided into stages, but not always linear. Stage 1: Relationship Building Foundation of effective counselling: strong therapeutic relationship built on trust, empathy, respect. Creates safe, non-judgmental environment. Counsellor Tasks: Establish Rapport: Make client comfortable via verbal cues, active listening, welcoming demeanor. Explain Confidentiality: Clearly outline limits/scope of confidentiality. Clarify Roles: Explain counsellor's role (facilitator, not advice-giver) and client's role (active participant). Communicate Empathy & Genuineness: Use empathetic understanding and genuine attitude. Stage 2: Problem Assessment Counsellor and client delve deeper to understand presenting problem. Collects/organizes information. Counsellor Tasks: Gather Information: Use open-ended questions to explore client's background, history. Identify Core Issues: Help client verbalize/clarify central issues. Observe Non-Verbal Cues: Pay attention to body language, emotional expression. Case Formulation: Develop theoretical understanding of client's problem to inform treatment plan. Stage 3: Goal Setting Counsellor and client establish clear, measurable, achievable goals for therapeutic process. Counsellor Tasks: Collaborate on Goals: Ensure client is active partner to increase commitment. Set SMART Goals: Use SMART framework (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-based). Prioritize Objectives: Help client focus on key, achievable goals. Stage 4: Intervention and Strategy Implementation Action-oriented phase; counsellor uses therapeutic techniques to help client achieve goals. Approach depends on theoretical orientation and client needs. Counsellor Tasks: Select Strategies: Choose appropriate interventions (e.g., cognitive-behavioral, person-centered). Implement & Adapt Techniques: Guide client through exercises, coping mechanisms, adjust approach based on progress. Support & Challenge Client: Balance support and constructive challenge to explore issues, consider alternative perspectives. Stage 5: Evaluation, Termination, or Referral Final stage: review client's progress, evaluate outcomes, bring therapeutic relationship to close. Counsellor Tasks: Evaluate Progress: Review goals, assess overall progress (feedback/assessment tools). Plan Termination: Prepare client for end of relationship, discuss process in advance, reinforce skills. Facilitate Closure: Help client process feelings associated with ending counselling (grief/loss). Consider Referral: Refer to another professional if needs not fully met or new issues arise. Attitudes of Counsellors Core beliefs/values guiding professional/ethical behavior. Create psychological conditions for client safety, understanding, motivation for change. Empathy: Understand and share client's feelings/perspective. Unconditional Positive Regard: Accept/value client regardless of thoughts, beliefs, behavior. Genuineness: Authentic, sincere, transparent; words/actions align with internal feelings. Non-Judgmental: Respect/accept client without imposing personal beliefs/evaluations. Skills of Counselling Foundational Skills Active Listening: Fully engaging, processing client's verbal/non-verbal communication (tone, body language, expressions). Verbal Affirmation: Cues like "I see," "Go on," "um-hmm". Observing Non-Verbal Cues: Noticing what client isn't saying, underlying emotions. Attending Behavior: Physically demonstrating attentiveness (open posture, eye contact, leaning). Empathy: Understand/share client's emotions without losing self. Validates experience, fosters trust. Reflecting Feelings: Stating back perceived emotions to show client is heard ($"You \text{ sound angry and hurt because...}"$). Genuineness (Congruence): Counsellor's authenticity, sincerity, transparency. Words/actions align with internal feelings. Unconditional Positive Regard: Accepting/valuing client as worthy, regardless of behavior/beliefs. Creates safe space. Patience: Change is gradual; accept setbacks, empower client to move at own pace. Communication and Intervention Skills Guide conversation, facilitate deeper insight. Questioning: Asking open-ended questions for richer, detailed information. Effective Questioning: Using "how," "what," "could" to explore thoughts/feelings. Avoiding Problematic Questions: Refraining from "why" (judgmental), avoiding bombarding. Paraphrasing: Restating client's words concisely to confirm understanding core message. Example: Client: "I can't get on with colleague, dread work." Counsellor: "Sounds like conflict affects enjoyment of job." Summarizing: Condensing/restating main themes/key points of session. Provides clear overview, tracks progress. Example: Counsellor: "Last week, we talked about anxiety peaks Sundays, negative thoughts. How has this week been?" Advanced and Specialized Skills Silence: Therapeutic tool for client reflection, processing emotions, gathering thoughts without pressure. Clarification: Asking for clarification when client's statement is vague/ambiguous. Ensures accurate understanding. Focusing: Guiding client to explore specific significant areas of conversation. Example: Client mentions family's disapproval, moves on. Counsellor guides back: "You mentioned family's disapproval. Can we talk about that?" Confrontation: Pointing out discrepancies/inconsistencies gently, empathetically. Brings unconscious patterns to awareness. Example: "You say you want to quit smoking, but just bought new pack. How do we make sense?" Self-Disclosure: Cautiously sharing personal, relevant experiences to build trust, normalize feelings. Guideline: Brief, client-focused, judiciously used. Psychoeducation: Providing relevant, evidence-based information about condition. Empowers clients to understand/cope. Example: Providing anxiety patient with relaxation techniques and physiological effects of anxiety. Crisis Intervention: Short-term, urgent assistance and emotional support during traumatic events/crises. Conflict Resolution: Helping clients develop skills for managing/resolving conflicts (assertive communication, understanding others' perspectives). Cultural Competence: Awareness, knowledge, skills to provide effective counselling to diverse cultural backgrounds. Practice and Development Skills are developed through education, training, supervision, self-reflection. Mock Sessions: Practice with peers/mentors for constructive feedback. Supervision: Ongoing supervision from experienced counsellors to identify biases, blind spots, ensure ethical practice. Self-Awareness: Continuous reflection on own biases, values, emotional triggers to prevent personal issues affecting relationship. Problems in Counselling Challenges requiring skill and patience. Client Resistance: Conscious/unconscious resistance due to fear/discomfort. Confidentiality Concerns: Balancing privacy with legal/ethical obligations (especially in harm cases). Transference & Countertransference: Client projecting feelings onto counsellor (transference) or vice versa (countertransference), interfering with process. Emotional Burnout: Counsellors at risk due to demanding nature of work. Assessing and Diagnosing Clients' Problems Information Gathering: Collect information via clinical interviews, standardized tests, psychosocial histories. Differential Diagnosis: Rule out alternative explanations for symptoms, especially with similar presentations. Clinical Formulation: Develop theoretically based explanation of presenting problems, background, evolution of issues. Selecting Counselling Strategies and Interventions Counsellor selects strategies based on theoretical approach and client needs, aimed at achieving collaboratively set goals. Psychoeducation: Provide clear, understandable information to client/family about condition, treatment, prognosis. Skill-Building: Teach specific skills (relaxation, stress management, communication) to cope effectively. Cognitive Restructuring: Help client identify/challenge distorted/unhelpful thought patterns. Changing Behavior Through Counselling Counselling facilitates behavioral change by helping clients gain self-awareness, develop skills. Insight & Motivation: Understand root causes of behavior, find internal motivation to change. Skill Practice: Practice new behaviors/coping mechanisms in safe, therapeutic environment, increasing confidence. Accountability & Support: Counsellor holds client accountable to goals, provides consistent support. Application of Counselling to Hospital Situations for Performance Improvement Counselling skills applied beyond direct patient care to improve staff performance, hospital operations. Employee Well-being & Burnout Prevention: Application: Hospital counsellors offer workshops on stress management, emotional intelligence, work-life balance. Performance Improvement: Reduces staff turnover, improves morale, decreases absenteeism. Example: Hospital implements program for debriefing sessions after critical incidents, helping staff process emotional impact. Conflict Resolution & Team Dynamics: Application: Counsellors mediate conflicts between team members, departments, staff/administration. Performance Improvement: Fosters collaborative, communicative work environment, leading to better team cohesion, patient care coordination. Example: Counsellor mediates between clashing department heads over resource allocation, leading to agreeable solution. Communication Skills Training: Application: Counsellors train staff on improving communication with patients, families, colleagues. Performance Improvement: Enhances patient satisfaction, reduces misunderstandings/medical errors. Example: Hospital uses feedback to identify communication need. Counselling team develops training for nurses on active listening/empathetic communication, improving HCAHPS scores. Change Management: Application: Counsellors support staff during major organizational changes (e.g., new EHR system, restructuring), addressing fears/concerns. Performance Improvement: Minimizes resistance to change, ensures smoother transition, maintains productivity. Example: Hospital transitions to new IT system. Counsellor meets with staff to discuss anxieties, gather feedback, help develop coping strategies, ensuring high adoption rates, minimal disruption.