Tube-to-Tubesheet Joints (ASME VIII-1)

Cheatsheet Content

1. Introduction to Tube-to-Tubesheet Joints Purpose: To join tubes to a tubesheet, forming a leak-tight and structurally sound connection in heat exchangers and boilers. ASME Section VIII, Division 1: Provides rules for the design, fabrication, inspection, and testing of unfired pressure vessels. Tube-to-tubesheet joints fall under these regulations. Key Considerations: Leak integrity Mechanical strength (resistance to pull-out, bending) Corrosion resistance Ease of fabrication and repair Cost effectiveness 2. Types of Tube-to-Tubesheet Joints Rolled Joints (Expanded Joints): Most common and economical method. Tube material is plastically deformed into grooves or against the bore of the tubesheet hole. Achieves leak-tightness and mechanical strength through interference fit. Can be supplemented with seal welding for enhanced integrity. Welded Joints: Used for more severe service conditions (high pressure, high temperature, corrosive fluids). Provides superior leak integrity and mechanical strength compared to rolled joints alone. Requires careful control of welding procedures and inspection. Types: Strength weld, seal weld, and combined strength/seal weld. Explosion Welded Joints: Specialized method using explosive energy to create a metallurgical bond. Provides excellent strength and leak-tightness, often used for dissimilar metals. Less common due to specialized equipment and safety requirements. 3. Rolled Joints: Design & Fabrication (ASME VIII-1) 3.1. Joint Configuration Grooves: Tubesheet holes often have one or more annular grooves to increase resistance to tube pull-out and improve leak-tightness. Typically, 1-3 grooves are used. Groove dimensions (width, depth) are critical. Tube Expansion: Tubes are expanded into the tubesheet hole using a tube expander. Expansion should extend beyond the tubesheet thickness, but not too far into the tube bundle. Controlled expansion is crucial to avoid over-thinning or over-hardening the tube. 3.2. Material Considerations Tube & Tubesheet Material: Compatibility is important for proper expansion and long-term performance. Hardness: Tubesheet material should generally be harder than the tube material for effective expansion. 3.3. Inspection Visual Inspection: For proper tube projection, absence of damage. Leak Testing: Hydrostatic or pneumatic testing of the completed vessel. Pull-out Tests: May be performed on test samples to verify joint strength. 4. Welded Joints: Design & Fabrication (ASME VIII-1) 4.1. Types of Welds Seal Weld: Primary purpose is leak-tightness, not strength. Typically small fillet welds. Often used in conjunction with rolled joints. ASME requires a rolled joint to take the full design load if a seal weld is used, unless the weld is qualified as a strength weld. Strength Weld: Designed to carry the full mechanical load (pressure, thermal stresses). Requires full penetration or partial penetration welds with adequate throat thickness. Typically includes a weld preparation (bevel) on the tubesheet or tube. Combined Strength/Seal Weld: A single weld designed to provide both strength and leak-tightness. 4.2. Weld Configurations (Examples) Internal Bore Weld: Weld made from inside the tube, typically for small tube diameters or when access to the face is restricted. Face Weld (Fillet Weld): Weld made on the tubesheet face, joining the tube end to the tubesheet. Common for seal welds or smaller strength welds. Full Penetration Weld: Weld that fully penetrates the thickness of the tube wall or tubesheet joint preparation. Achieved with appropriate bevels on the tubesheet and/or tube. 4.3. Weld Preparation Tubesheet Hole Preparation: Counter-bore, chamfer, or J-groove preparations are common to facilitate welding and achieve required weld profiles. Tube End Preparation: May include chamfering or facing. 4.4. Welding Procedures WPS (Welding Procedure Specification): Must be qualified in accordance with ASME Section IX. PQR (Procedure Qualification Record): Documents the successful qualification of the WPS. Welders/Welding Operators: Must be qualified per ASME Section IX. Process Control: Critical for ensuring consistent weld quality (e.g., heat input, shielding gas, filler material). 5. ASME VIII-1 Requirements for Welded Joints 5.1. General Requirements (UG-37, UW-20) Stress Analysis: Joints must be designed to withstand design pressures and other loads. Joint Efficiency: Applicable for strength welds joining pressure parts. Postweld Heat Treatment (PWHT): May be required based on material, thickness, and service conditions (UCS-56, UHA-32). 5.2. Specific Requirements for Welded Tube-to-Tubesheet Joints (UW-20) Minimum Weld Dimensions: For strength welds, the leg dimension or throat thickness must be sufficient to develop the required strength of the tube. Minimum weld throat for fillet welds often specified as $1/4$ times the tube wall thickness, or $3 \text{ mm}$ ($1/8 \text{ in.}$), whichever is less, but adequate for design. Fillet Weld Profile: Must be smooth and free from undercut, overlap, and other defects. Full Penetration Welds: If full penetration welds are specified, they must be verified by NDE. Tube Projection: Tubes should project sufficiently beyond the tubesheet face to allow for proper welding, typically $3 \text{ mm}$ ($1/8 \text{ in.}$) minimum. 6. Inspection and Testing (ASME VIII-1) 6.1. Non-Destructive Examination (NDE) Visual Testing (VT): Required for all welds to check for surface imperfections, proper profile, and absence of gross defects. Liquid Penetrant Testing (PT) or Magnetic Particle Testing (MT): Often required on the completed welds to detect surface-breaking defects. Extent may vary based on joint type, material, and service (e.g., 100% for severe service, spot checks for others). Radiographic Testing (RT) or Ultrasonic Testing (UT): Rarely used for small fillet or seal welds due to geometry. May be required for full penetration strength welds or specialized internal bore welds to detect internal defects. 6.2. Leak Testing Hydrostatic Test (UG-99): Required for all pressure vessels. The vessel is filled with water and pressurized to $1.3 \times \text{MAWP} \times \text{stress ratio}$. Pneumatic Test (UG-100): May be used instead of hydrostatic if certain conditions are met (e.g., vessel cannot be filled with water, highly hazardous fluid). Pressure is typically $1.1 \times \text{MAWP}$. Bubble Test: Used for localized leak detection, often with a soap solution. Helium Leak Test: Highly sensitive test for detecting very small leaks, often used for critical applications. 6.3. Post-Fabrication Inspection Dimensional Checks: Verify tube projection, concentricity, etc. Hardness Testing: May be performed on heat-affected zones (HAZ) of welds if specified, particularly for materials susceptible to hardening. 7. Common Defects and Remedies Rolled Joints: Over-expansion: Tube thinning, work hardening, cracking. Remedy: Control expansion depth and pressure. Under-expansion: Insufficient strength, leak paths. Remedy: Re-expand or re-roll. Scoring/Damage: Due to improper tooling. Remedy: Replace tube. Welded Joints: Undercut: Groove melted into the base metal adjacent to the weld toe. Remedy: Adjust welding parameters, repair by welding. Porosity: Gas pockets within the weld metal. Remedy: Improve shielding gas, clean base metal. Incomplete Penetration: Weld metal doesn't fully fuse joint thickness. Remedy: Adjust welding parameters, re-weld. Cracks: Can be hot or cold cracks. Remedy: Re-weld after excavation, consider PWHT, material selection. Lack of Fusion: Weld metal not fusing with base metal or previous weld pass. Remedy: Adjust welding parameters, improve joint preparation. 8. Repair of Tube-to-Tubesheet Joints (ASME VIII-1) ASME Repair Procedures: Repairs must be performed in accordance with the original code of construction and approved by an Authorized Inspector. Rolled Joint Repair: Minor leaks may be re-rolled. Severely damaged tubes often require plugging or replacement. Welded Joint Repair: Defective welds must be excavated and re-welded using qualified procedures. Extent of excavation and repair welding depends on the defect type and size. Re-inspection (NDE and leak testing) is required after repair. Plugging Tubes: For irreparable tubes, plugging is an option to isolate the tube from the process fluid. Plugs must be designed for full design pressure and temperature. Plugs can be mechanical (expanded) or welded. ASME VIII-1 provides guidance on plugging, ensuring the remaining tubesheet ligament and adjacent tubes are not overstressed.