Lithium-Based Batteries in Stationary Ap

Cheatsheet Content

1. Introduction to Lithium-Based Batteries Purpose: Guide for objective evaluation of lithium-based energy storage for stationary applications, complementing IEEE Std 1679-2020. Scope: Focuses on secondary (rechargeable) lithium-ion (Li-ion), lithium-ion polymer, lithium-sulfur, and emerging solid-state lithium technologies. Applications: Grid-scale energy storage, uninterruptible power supplies (UPS), telecommunications, data centers, peak shaving, load leveling, renewable energy integration. Exclusions: Primary (non-rechargeable) lithium batteries. Detailed sizing, installation, maintenance, and testing methods (unless directly related to evaluation). 2. Fundamental Concepts & Terminology Cell: The basic electrochemical energy storage unit. Battery: An assembly of one or more cells, often in a module or pack. Module: A group of cells connected in series/parallel within a single housing. Pack: An assembly of modules, often with a Battery Management System (BMS) and thermal management. State of Charge (SOC): The available capacity of a battery, expressed as a percentage of its rated capacity (0% to 100%). Crucial for operational control. State of Health (SOH): A measure of the battery's overall condition, reflecting its ability to deliver specified performance compared to a new battery (e.g., remaining capacity, power capability). Expressed as a percentage. Depth of Discharge (DOD): The amount of energy removed from a battery, expressed as a percentage of its rated capacity. A higher DOD generally leads to faster degradation. Cycle Life: The number of charge-discharge cycles a battery can perform before its capacity falls below a specified percentage (e.g., 80% of initial capacity). Highly dependent on DOD, C-rate, and temperature. Calendar Life: The total operational lifespan of a battery regardless of cycling, influenced by time, temperature, and SOC. C-rate: A measure of the rate at which a battery is charged or discharged relative to its maximum capacity. 1C means the battery is charged/discharged in 1 hour; 0.5C in 2 hours; 2C in 30 minutes. Energy Density: The amount of energy stored per unit mass (Wh/kg) or per unit volume (Wh/L). Power Density: The amount of power delivered per unit mass (W/kg) or per unit volume (W/L). Open-Circuit Voltage (OCV): The voltage across the battery terminals when no current is flowing (i.e., not connected to a load or charger). Varies with SOC. Internal Resistance: The opposition to current flow within the battery, causing voltage drop and heat generation. Increases with aging and low temperature. 3. Lithium-Ion Battery Chemistries (5.2) 3.1 General Reaction Mechanism Anode (Negative Electrode): During discharge, lithium ions ($Li^+$) are released from the anode and move through the electrolyte to the cathode. Electrons flow through the external circuit. During charge, the process reverses. Materials: Primarily graphite (layered carbon), but also Lithium Titanate (LTO), silicon compounds, niobium oxides. Cathode (Positive Electrode): During discharge, lithium ions are intercalated into the cathode material. Materials: Lithiated metal oxides (e.g., LMO, NMC, NCA) or lithiated metal phosphates (e.g., LFP, LMFP). Electrolyte: A medium (liquid or solid) containing a lithium salt (e.g., $LiPF_6$, $LiBF_4$) dissolved in organic solvents, facilitating $Li^+$ transport. Separator: A porous membrane physically separating anode and cathode, preventing short circuits while allowing $Li^+$ passage. Solid-Electrolyte Interphase (SEI): A passivating layer formed on the anode surface (especially graphite) during the initial charge cycles. Essential for stable operation, but its growth contributes to capacity fade. LTO anodes typically do not form an SEI. 3.2 Common Cathode Chemistries & Characteristics Relative performance comparison (refer to Figure 2 usually found in source document): Lithium Manganese Oxide (LMO): Pros: Good power capability, relatively safe, low cost. Cons: Lower energy density, moderate cycle life. Use: Power tools, medical devices, some EVs. Lithium Nickel Manganese Cobalt Oxide (NMC): Pros: High energy density, good power, decent cycle life. Balance of performance. Cons: Moderate safety (higher nickel content increases reactivity), higher cost than LMO/LFP. Use: EVs, grid storage, portable electronics. Ratios (e.g., NMC 111, 532, 622, 811) indicate Ni:Mn:Co proportions, impacting energy vs. safety. Lithium Nickel Cobalt Aluminum Oxide (NCA): Pros: Very high energy density, good power. Cons: Less stable than NMC, higher safety concerns, expensive. Use: High-performance EVs (e.g., Tesla). Lithium Iron Phosphate (LFP): Pros: Excellent safety (very stable crystal structure), long cycle life, good power capability, wide operating temperature range, low cost. Cons: Lower energy density, relatively flat voltage profile (harder to estimate SOC via OCV). Use: Stationary storage, electric buses, some EVs. Lithium Manganese-Iron Phosphate (LMFP): Pros: Improved energy density over LFP while retaining good safety and cycle life. Cons: Still under development for widespread commercialization. 3.3 Anode Chemistries Graphite: Most common. Good capacity, cycle life, and cost. Forms SEI. Lithium Titanate (LTO): Pros: Extremely long cycle life, very fast charging/discharging, excellent low-temperature performance, very high safety (no SEI formation, minimal dendrite risk). Cons: Very low operating voltage (lower energy density), higher cost. Use: Applications requiring extreme cycle life and power, such as grid frequency regulation, heavy-duty EVs. Silicon Compounds: High theoretical capacity, but suffer from significant volume expansion during lithiation, leading to mechanical degradation and cycle life issues. Often used as an additive to graphite. 4. Cell & Battery Construction (5.4) 4.1 Cell Form Factors Cylindrical Cells: Electrodes wound into a jelly roll, housed in a rigid metal cylinder. Pros: High mechanical stability, good internal pressure management, widely standardized (e.g., 18650, 21700). Cons: Lower packing density in a battery pack due to cylindrical shape. Prismatic Cells: Electrodes stacked or folded into rectangular layers, housed in a rigid metal or aluminum casing. Pros: Efficient space utilization, good thermal management potential. Cons: Can require external compression to maintain performance and life. Pouch Cells: Electrodes stacked in flexible, laminated foil pouches. Pros: Highest packing density, lightweight, flexible design, good thermal dissipation. Cons: Less mechanically robust, susceptible to swelling, requires external compression in a module. 4.2 Battery Architecture (Figure 7) Series Connection (S): Cells connected positive to negative to increase total voltage (e.g., 10S for 36V nominal). Parallel Connection (P): Cells connected positive to positive and negative to negative to increase total capacity and current capability (e.g., 4P for 4x cell capacity). Notation: xSyP (y parallel strings of x series cells) or xPyS (x parallel cells, y series groups). Modular Design: Cells are grouped into modules, which are then connected to form a battery pack or system. This facilitates scalability, maintenance, and fault isolation. 5. Battery Management System (BMS) (5.8.1) The "brain" of the battery system, crucial for safety, performance, and longevity. Monitoring: Cell Voltage: Individual cell voltage monitoring to prevent overcharge/overdischarge. Battery Voltage: Overall pack voltage. Current: Charge and discharge current. Temperature: Multiple temperature sensors across cells/modules to detect hot spots and prevent thermal runaway. SOC/SOH Estimation: Complex algorithms (e.g., Coulomb counting, Kalman filters) to estimate real-time SOC and long-term SOH. Protection: Overcharge/Overdischarge Protection: Disconnects the battery if cell voltages exceed/fall below safe limits. Overcurrent Protection: Limits current during charge/discharge to safe levels. Overtemperature/Undertemperature Protection: Disconnects or reduces power if temperature is outside safe operating range. Short Circuit Protection: Rapidly disconnects the battery in case of an internal or external short. Cell Balancing: Equalizes voltages among parallel-connected cells within a series string, preventing individual cells from becoming overcharged or overdischarged. Passive Balancing: Dissipates excess energy from higher-voltage cells as heat through resistors. Simpler, lower cost, but less efficient. Active Balancing: Transfers energy from higher-voltage cells to lower-voltage cells. More complex, higher cost, but more efficient and effective. Communication: Interfaces with external systems (e.g., inverter, supervisory controller, cloud) for data exchange and control. Contactor/Relay Control: Manages main power switches to connect or disconnect the battery from the load/charger. Pre-charge Circuit: A resistor in parallel with the main contactor used to slowly charge system capacitors when connecting the battery, preventing large inrush currents that could damage components. 6. Thermal Management System (TMS) (5.8.2) Maintains the battery within its optimal temperature range, critical for performance, life, and safety. Impacts: High Temperatures: Accelerate degradation, increase internal resistance, risk of thermal runaway. Low Temperatures: Reduce available capacity, increase internal resistance, limit power, risk of lithium plating during charging. Methods: Air Cooling: Natural convection or forced air (fans). Simple, low cost, but less effective for large systems or high power. Liquid Cooling/Heating: Circulating coolant (e.g., glycol-water mixture) through channels or cold plates. Highly effective for precise temperature control. Phase Change Materials (PCMs): Absorb latent heat when changing phase (e.g., solid to liquid) to manage temperature spikes. Refrigerant Cooling: Direct expansion refrigeration for demanding applications. Internal Heating: Resistors or reverse current flow to warm batteries in cold environments. 7. Performance Characteristics (5.6) Capacity (Ah/Wh): Total charge/energy stored. Rated capacity typically at 1C discharge. Voltage (V): Nominal voltage, working voltage range. Power (W): Maximum continuous or peak power output. Efficiency: Round-trip energy efficiency (energy out / energy in). Typically 85-95% for Li-ion. Self-discharge: Rate at which a battery loses charge when not in use. Very low for Li-ion ( Impedance/Internal Resistance: Increases with aging, low temperature, and low SOC, leading to power loss and heat. 8. Aging Mechanisms & Failure Modes (6.3) 8.1 Aging Mechanisms Calendar Aging: Capacity loss and resistance increase over time, even without cycling. Accelerated by high temperature and high SOC. Cycle Aging: Degradation due to repeated charge/discharge cycles. Influenced by DOD, C-rate, temperature, and specific chemistry. Primary Mechanisms: SEI Growth: Continuous reaction of electrolyte with anode, consuming lithium and electrolyte, increasing internal resistance. Lithium Plating: Formation of metallic lithium on the anode surface, especially at low temperatures, high charge rates, or high SOC. Irreversible, consumes active lithium, and can lead to dendrite formation. Active Material Loss: Degradation, cracking, or dissolution of electrode materials. Electrolyte Decomposition: Breakdown of electrolyte components. Current Collector Corrosion: Degradation of the metal foils (copper for anode, aluminum for cathode). 8.2 Failure Modes Overcharge: Charging beyond safe voltage. Can lead to lithium plating, electrolyte decomposition, oxygen evolution, internal short circuits, and thermal runaway. Overdischarge: Discharging below safe voltage. Can cause copper dissolution from the anode current collector, which then plates on the separator, leading to internal micro-short circuits and permanent capacity loss. Internal Short Circuit: Caused by manufacturing defects, dendrite formation, separator damage (e.g., from mechanical stress), or severe overcharge/overdischarge. Can lead to rapid discharge, heating, and thermal runaway. External Short Circuit: Accidental shorting of battery terminals. Leads to very high currents, rapid heating, and potential fire/explosion. Thermal Runaway: A self-sustaining chain reaction where increasing temperature causes further exothermic reactions, leading to a rapid and uncontrolled temperature rise, gas release, fire, and potentially explosion. Triggered by internal/external shorts, overcharge, mechanical abuse, or high external temperatures. Mechanical Abuse: Puncturing, crushing, or impacts can damage internal structures, leading to internal shorts and thermal runaway. Electronic Failures: Malfunction of BMS components, sensors, or communication systems, potentially leading to unsafe operation or system shutdown. 9. Safety & Regulatory Considerations (6.4, 8) 9.1 Safety Design Principles Intrinsic Safety: Selection of inherently safer chemistries (e.g., LFP, LTO). Passive Safety: Design features that inherently prevent or mitigate hazards (e.g., pressure relief vents, current interrupt devices (CIDs) in cells, thermally activated shutdown separators). Active Safety: BMS and TMS actively monitor and control the battery to prevent unsafe conditions. Preventing Propagation: Design of modules/packs to contain thermal events within a single cell or module, preventing spread to adjacent cells. Abuse Tolerance: Ability of the battery system to withstand abnormal conditions (overcharge, overdischarge, external short, mechanical impact) without catastrophic failure. 9.2 Fire & Explosion Control (6.4.1.6, 6.4.1.7) Thermal Runaway Gases: During thermal runaway, cells release flammable, toxic gases (e.g., $CO, H_2$, hydrocarbons). Ventilation: Critical to dilute flammable gases below their Lower Flammable Limit (LFL) and remove heat. NFPA 69 (Standard on Explosion Prevention Systems) guidance. Fire Suppression: Agents: Halon-replacement agents (e.g., FK-5-1-12, HFC-227ea), inert gases (nitrogen, argon), water (can cool, but may react with certain battery materials or propagate electrical faults). Containment: Fire-rated enclosures and compartmentalization for large installations. Explosion Protection: If flammable gas accumulation cannot be prevented, explosion relief panels (NFPA 68) or explosion suppression systems may be required. 9.3 Safety Standards & Regulations Transportation: UN 38.3 (tests for safe transport of lithium batteries), ICAO/IATA (air transport), IMDG (maritime), ADR/RID (road/rail). Strict rules on SOC for air cargo (e.g., 30%). Product Safety (Cells/Batteries): IEC 62133, UL 1642, UL 2054. Stationary Storage System Safety: UL 9540/9540A: Crucial for stationary energy storage systems (ESS) in the USA. UL 9540 covers system safety; UL 9540A is a test method for evaluating thermal runaway fire propagation. NFPA 855: Standard for the Installation of Stationary Energy Storage Systems. International Fire Code (IFC): Incorporates requirements for ESS installation. IEEE Std 1679: Guide for the Application and Evaluation of Battery Energy Storage Systems. Environmental: RoHS (Restriction of Hazardous Substances), WEEE (Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment) directives for recycling and disposal. 10. Evaluation Techniques (9) 10.1 Application-Specific Requirements Power vs. Energy: Is the primary need high power delivery (e.g., UPS, frequency regulation) or high energy storage (e.g., load shifting, renewable integration)? This dictates chemistry and cell selection. Cycle Life & Calendar Life: Match the battery's expected life to the project's operational lifespan, considering target DOD and operating conditions. Operating Environment: Temperature range, humidity, altitude, vibration, seismic requirements. Efficiency: Overall system efficiency, including battery, PCS (Power Conversion System), and thermal management. Footprint/Weight: Space and weight constraints for installation. Warranty: Manufacturer's warranty on capacity, cycle life, and defects. 10.2 Performance Assessment Testing: Performance testing (capacity, power, efficiency) under simulated application conditions. Modeling & Simulation: Using battery models to predict performance and degradation over time. Data Analytics: Leveraging BMS data for real-time performance monitoring, fault detection, and predictive maintenance. Degradation Curves: Understanding how capacity and power degrade over cycles and calendar time for the specific chemistry and operating profile. 10.3 Safety Assessment Hazard Analysis: FMEA (Failure Modes and Effects Analysis), HAZOP (Hazard and Operability Study) for identifying potential failure points and their consequences. Certification: Verification of compliance with relevant safety standards (e.g., UL 9540) by accredited third parties. Emergency Response Plan: Develop procedures for handling thermal events, fires, and other emergencies. 10.4 Balance of System (BOS) Power Conversion System (PCS): Inverters/chargers converting DC battery power to AC grid power. Electrical Infrastructure: Cabling, switchgear, transformers. Mechanical Infrastructure: Racks, enclosures, containment, foundations. HVAC: Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning for the battery enclosure. Fire Detection & Suppression: Sensors (smoke, gas, heat), fire alarms, and active suppression systems. SCADA/Control System: Supervisory control and data acquisition for overall system management.