Theories of Crime

Cheatsheet Content

### Biological Theories of Crime Biological theories suggest that genetic, neurological, or physiological factors predispose individuals to criminal behavior. - **Factors:** Genetics, brain abnormalities, hormonal imbalances, evolutionary adaptations. - **Quote:** Cesare Lombroso (1876), often considered the father of modern criminology, proposed the concept of "atavism," suggesting criminals were evolutionary throwbacks. He wrote, "The born criminal is an atavistic being who reproduces in his person the ferocious instincts of primitive humanity and the inferior animals." - **Relevance to Pakistan:** While direct biological determinism is largely discredited, factors like mental health issues (which can have biological components) or substance abuse (impacting brain chemistry) are relevant. However, attributing crime solely to biology risks ignoring socio-economic factors prevalent in Pakistan. For example, studies on drug addiction and its link to crime might touch on biological vulnerabilities, but the social context of drug availability and poverty often plays a larger role. ### Psychological Theories of Crime Psychological theories focus on individual personality, learning, and cognitive processes as explanations for criminal behavior. - **Factors:** Personality disorders (e.g., antisocial personality disorder), cognitive distortions, learned behavior (e.g., social learning theory), moral development. - **Quote:** Albert Bandura's Social Learning Theory (1977) states, "Learning would be exceedingly laborious, not to mention hazardous, if people had to rely solely on the effects of their own actions to inform them what to do. Fortunately, most human behavior is learned observationally through modeling." - **Relevance to Pakistan:** Psychological factors like impulsivity, aggression, or lack of empathy can contribute to criminal acts. The impact of trauma, especially in conflict-ridden areas or due to domestic violence, can lead to psychological issues that manifest as criminal behavior. For instance, studies on juvenile delinquency in Pakistan often highlight family environment, peer influence, and psychological distress as contributing factors. ### Social Theories of Crime Social theories emphasize societal structures, institutions, and social interactions as primary drivers of criminal behavior. - **Factors:** Poverty, inequality, social disorganization, cultural norms, peer groups, lack of opportunity, breakdown of social controls. - **Quote:** Émile Durkheim (1897), in his work on anomie, noted, "Crime is present in all societies of all types. There is no society that is not confronted with the problem of criminality. Its form changes, the acts it labels as criminal are not everywhere the same, but everywhere and always, there have been men who have behaved in such a way as to draw punishment upon themselves." - **Relevance to Pakistan:** This category is highly relevant to understanding crime in Pakistan, where socio-economic disparities, rapid urbanization, and institutional weaknesses are significant. Issues like unemployment, illiteracy, and the breakdown of traditional family structures in urban slums can be analyzed through a social lens. ### R.K. Merton's Strain Theory & Anomie Robert Merton's Strain Theory (1938) posits that crime results from the strain individuals experience when they cannot achieve culturally approved goals (e.g., wealth) through legitimate means. Anomie refers to a state of normlessness or deregulation in society. - **Factors:** Discrepancy between cultural goals and legitimate means, social inequality, blocked opportunities, societal pressure to succeed. - **Quote:** Merton wrote, "It is only when a system of cultural values extols, virtually above all else, certain common success-goals for the population at large while the social structure rigorously restricts or completely closes access to approved modes of reaching these goals for a considerable part of the same population, that deviant behavior ensues." - **Concept of Anomie:** Durkheim's original concept of anomie focused on the breakdown of social norms due to rapid social change. Merton applied this to the American dream, where the emphasis on material success combined with limited opportunities for the poor creates a state of anomie, leading to adaptation like innovation (crime). - **Relevance to Pakistan:** This theory strongly applies to Pakistan. The pervasive issues of poverty, unemployment, and corruption mean that many individuals, particularly youth, face significant barriers to achieving economic success through legitimate channels. This "strain" can lead to engaging in criminal activities like theft, fraud, or even joining extremist groups as a perceived path to status or survival. The high value placed on material success in society, coupled with widespread unemployment, creates anomic conditions. - **Example:** A young man from a low-income background in a big city, unable to find a stable job despite education, might resort to street crime or drug dealing to achieve financial stability and social recognition. ### Social Disorganization Theory Developed by Shaw and McKay (1942), this theory links crime rates to neighborhood ecological characteristics, particularly the breakdown of social institutions and informal social control in certain areas. - **Factors:** Poverty, residential mobility, ethnic heterogeneity, weak social ties, lack of collective efficacy, breakdown of community institutions (schools, churches). - **Quote:** Shaw and McKay observed that "areas characterized by high rates of delinquency... were also characterized by poverty, physical deterioration, and high rates of population turnover." - **Relevance to Pakistan:** Highly relevant in the context of Pakistan's rapid urbanization and the growth of informal settlements or "katchi abadis." These areas often exhibit high poverty, transient populations, and weak community structures, leading to a breakdown of informal social controls. This creates an environment where crime can flourish due to lack of parental supervision, weak community bonds, and limited institutional presence. - **Example:** A densely populated urban slum in Karachi or Lahore, with high rates of migration, poor housing, and limited access to quality education or policing, might show higher rates of street crime, drug use, and gang activity due to social disorganization. ### Social Differential Association Theory Edwin Sutherland's Differential Association Theory (1939) proposes that criminal behavior is learned through interaction with others, primarily within intimate personal groups. - **Factors:** Exposure to definitions favorable to law violation, frequency, duration, priority, and intensity of association with criminal patterns. - **Quote:** Sutherland stated, "A person becomes delinquent because of an excess of definitions favorable to violation of law over definitions unfavorable to violation of law." - **Relevance to Pakistan:** This theory explains how individuals, particularly youth, can be drawn into criminal activities through peer influence and exposure to criminal subcultures. In environments where criminal networks (e.g., drug cartels, militant groups, organized crime) are prevalent, individuals learn the techniques, motivations, and rationalizations for crime. - **Example:** Young individuals in certain neighborhoods might be exposed to older peers or family members involved in drug peddling or extortion. Through these interactions, they learn the "how-to" of crime, the justifications for it, and the values associated with such activities, eventually adopting these behaviors themselves. ### Labelling Theory Labelling theory, prominent in the 1960s, argues that crime is not inherent in an act but is a social construct. It focuses on how societal reactions and the application of labels (e.g., "criminal," "deviant") can lead to further deviance. - **Factors:** Social reaction, stigmatization, master status, self-fulfilling prophecy, power dynamics in defining deviance. - **Quote:** Howard Becker (1963) famously wrote, "Social groups create deviance by making rules whose infraction constitutes deviance, and by applying those rules to particular people and labeling them as outsiders." - **Relevance to Pakistan:** This theory highlights the impact of the justice system and societal attitudes on individuals. Once labeled as a "criminal" or "terrorist" in Pakistan, an individual may face significant social stigma, making it difficult to reintegrate into society, find legitimate employment, or escape further criminal involvement. This can lead to a "self-fulfilling prophecy" where the labeled individual internalizes the deviant identity. - **Example:** An individual arrested for a minor offense and subsequently labeled as a "criminal" might struggle to find a job or be accepted back into their community. This social exclusion can push them towards further deviant behavior as it becomes their primary identity. The "war on terror" in Pakistan has also seen individuals from certain areas or backgrounds being labeled, leading to potential stigmatization and further marginalization.